So Ramona lives on this farm with her two kids, Taylor and Annie. Her husband David died in a car crash, and she's been really struggling ever since. But here's the big secret - she's been lying to her kids about what happened. She told them their dad was driving the car when it crashed, but actually she was the one driving. She was upset and distracted during a fight with her husband about how unhappy she felt with their life. The crash happened because she wasn't paying attention to the road.
Now Ramona feels terrible guilt about this. She blames herself for killing her husband, and she's also dealing with being disabled from the same crash. Taking care of two kids alone, running a farm, and carrying this huge secret is making her very depressed. She's not a bad mom, but she's struggling badly and sometimes gets really angry or acts strange.
Then this creepy woman shows up in their yard. She's dressed all in black and just stands there saying "Today's the day." At first, it seems like the kids can see her too, which makes it feel like a real ghost or demon. Ramona tells her kids to stay away from the woman, but her son Taylor gets frustrated and wants his mom to do something about it.
But here's where it gets weird. Strange things start happening around the house. Their dog Charlie disappears. The power keeps going out. Food in the freezer starts rotting. The house feels cold and dark. Ramona starts hearing voices and seeing things that might not be real.
The really important part is that the woman in black isn't actually a ghost or demon at all. She's a symbol of Ramona's depression and her thoughts about killing herself. Remember, Ramona has been praying for "strength," but what she really means is she wants the strength to end her own life because she can't handle the guilt and pain anymore. The woman appeared because Ramona's depression has gotten so bad that she's seriously thinking about suicide.
The woman is scary because she's not mean or angry. She's gentle and understanding. She talks to Ramona like she cares about her, which makes her even more dangerous. She's like that voice in your head that tells you "it would be easier to just give up" or "everyone would be better off without you." That's what makes her so terrifying - she represents the seductive side of depression that tries to convince you that death is the answer.
As the movie goes on, Ramona gets worse and worse. She starts imagining herself hurting her kids, and there's this really scary scene where she almost actually stabs her daughter Annie with a knife. Her kids become afraid of their own mother, which makes everything even more heartbreaking.
The woman keeps getting closer to the house, and eventually she leads Ramona out to the woods with a gun. She's going to help Ramona shoot herself. But right before it happens, the kids and the dog come back, and the woman disappears.
Now here's where things get really tricky and the movie becomes confusing. After that scene in the woods where Ramona was about to shoot herself, everything suddenly changes completely. The house looks perfect - clean, bright, and welcoming. The electricity works perfectly. The dog Charlie is alive and happy, running around like nothing bad ever happened. Everything that was broken or wrong is suddenly fixed.
Ramona is now calm and loving with her kids. She hugs them warmly and acts like the caring mother she used to be. When her son Taylor asks "Will the woman come back?" Ramona answers very peacefully, "We'll be ready next time." She doesn't seem scared or upset anymore. She seems... at peace.
But there are weird clues that something isn't right. There's this painting that shows Ramona and the woman in black merged together, like they're the same person. Even stranger, the signature on the painting says "Ramona" but it's written backwards. The house also has a new name - "Iris Haven" - which wasn't there before.
So what really happened? The movie gives us three different ways to understand the ending:
Theory 1: Ramona Actually Died
Most people think this is what really happened. When Ramona was in the woods with the gun, she did pull the trigger and kill herself. Everything after that - the perfect house, the happy kids, the living dog - is just her imagination as she's dying. It's like her brain's way of comforting her in her final moments, showing her the life she wished she could have had.
Think about it: everything is too perfect. Dogs don't just come back from the dead. Houses don't magically repair themselves. The backwards signature is like a clue that this isn't real - it's backwards because it's the opposite of reality. Ramona died, but her dying brain is creating this beautiful fantasy where she's a good mom and everything is okay.
Theory 2: Ramona Survived and Got Better
Some people think Ramona didn't actually shoot herself. Maybe when her kids and dog came back, she realized she didn't want to die after all. Maybe she threw the gun away and decided to live. In this version, the woman in black disappears because Ramona finally chose life over death.
The perfect house and living dog could be symbols of her mental state getting better. When you're very depressed, everything feels broken and hopeless. But when you start to recover, the world looks brighter and more beautiful. The backwards signature could mean that while her depression isn't gone forever, she now understands it and is ready to fight it if it comes back.
Theory 3: The Whole Thing Was An Imagination
This is the most complicated theory. Some people think Ramona actually died in the original car crash along with her husband, and the entire movie takes place in some kind of underworld. She's stuck there, dealing with her guilt and trying to decide whether to move on to whatever comes next or stay trapped in her guilt forever.
In this version, the woman in black is like a guide helping Ramona make her final choice. The ending would be Ramona finally accepting what happened and being ready to move on to the afterlife, either to be with her husband or to find peace.
The movie is designed to be confusing because depression itself is confusing. When someone is suicidal, it's hard to tell if they're getting better or just getting better at hiding their pain. The movie reflects this uncertainty.
But for me, the clues point to the sad truth: Ramona probably did kill herself. The perfect ending is too perfect to be real. The backwards signature, the magical repairs, the resurrection of the dog - these are all signs that we're seeing a fantasy, not reality.
The really heartbreaking part is that Ramona's final thoughts weren't about her own pain. They were about being a good mother. Even as she was dying, she was imagining herself hugging her kids and being the parent she always wanted to be. Her depression told her she was a terrible mother, but her dying fantasy shows that deep down, she knew she loved her children more than anything.
The movie doesn't give us a clear answer because real life doesn't always give us clear answers either. Sometimes we don't know if someone who seemed to be getting better was actually planning to hurt themselves. Sometimes the people we love the most are fighting battles we can't see. And sometimes, no matter how much we love someone, we can't save them from their own mind.
That is why this movie is so disturbing and sad. It's not about monsters or ghosts. It's about how mental illness can destroy a family from the inside, and how someone who seems fine on the outside might actually be fighting a terrible battle in their mind.
Watch on Apple TV or Amazon Prime