Ryan Coogler's Sinners feels like the kind of movie that's going to spark heated conversations long after you leave the theater. It's a bold, ambitious film that throws together genres like ingredients in a pot – sometimes it works beautifully, other times it feels a bit messy. Let me break down what actually happens, because the story is more complex than the trailers let on.
We start with twin brothers, both of them played by Michael B. Jordan, who've been working for the Chicago Outfit, basically as muscle for the mob. They've managed to steal a significant amount of money from their criminal employers and decide to flee back to their childhood home in the Mississippi Delta around 1932. This isn't just any homecoming though – they're returning to a place where being Black, in the Jim Crow South means constant danger, but they have a plan. Using their stolen mob money, they purchase a sawmill from a local white landowner who has ties to the Klan. It's a risky move, but they're determined to create something positive for their community.
The brothers don't stop there - they also establish a juke joint, which becomes this vibrant community space where Black folks can gather, drink, dance, and listen to live blues music. For a while, things seem to be working out. The sawmill provides jobs and economic independence, while the juke joint becomes the heart of the community's cultural life. But this is where things get weird, and I mean genuinely supernatural weird.
There's this character named Sammie who has an almost mystical connection to music – specifically the blues. When he performs, something otherworldly happens. His music doesn't just entertain, it seems to reach across time itself, summoning spirits and opening doorways between past and present. During one particularly intense performance at the juke joint, his music triggers something catastrophic. An Irish vampire named Remmick, who's been hiding in the shadows and watching the community, launches a full scale supernatural assault on them.
This isn't your typical vampire attack either. Remmick isn't just hunting for blood – he's trying to absorb the entire community into his vampire collective, erasing their individual identities and cultural connections in the process. What follows is this intense supernatural siege where the juke joint becomes a battleground, and everyone inside has to fight not just for their lives, but for their very souls and cultural identity.
What really caught me off guard was how the film uses music as this mystical force. There's this transcendent blues performance that literally opens doorways between past and present, summoning spirits and triggering a vampire attack that turns the entire night into a supernatural siege. The way Coogler weaves together personal trauma, cultural memory, and survival horror is genuinely unique, even if it doesn't always land perfectly. The story jumps forward decades to show us an elderly bluesman still haunted by the choices he made that night, which gives the whole thing this melancholy weight.
I'll be honest – the pacing in the first act had me wondering where this was all going. I found it meandering and unclear. But looking back, I think that slower build was intentional. This isn't really a plot-driven film, it's all about the characters – Smoke, Stack, and Sammie - three Black men trying to build something for themselves in a world that doesn't want them to succeed. Their internal struggles between tradition and modernity, faith and fatalism, feel way more important than any vampire mythology. Sammie's ability to channel spirits through his music becomes this beautiful metaphor for how music carries identity, history, and power across generations.
Now, about those vampires – they're not your typical bloodsuckers. The main antagonist, Remmick, is this Irish immigrant vampire who's less pure evil and more tragic figure. He's desperately trying to recreate a lost sense of community by literally consuming another one. It's a pretty heavy metaphor for how outsiders sometimes try to take over and control other people's cultures. Some people felt the "white vampires versus Black community" setup was cliché, but I think Coogler digs deeper than that. Remmick's victims aren't just killed – they're absorbed into this collective where their individuality and family history get completely erased. That is genuinely unsettling in ways that go beyond typical horror.
The film definitely has some frustrating loose ends though. There are these intriguing Choctaw vampire hunters who show up and then basically disappear from the story. Characters like Grace and Bo Chow feel underdeveloped, and the aftermath of everything that happens to the town gets glossed over. I kept waiting for these threads to pay off, and when they didn't, it left the whole thing feeling slightly unfinished. Plus, for a movie that bills itself as horror, it takes quite a while to deliver any real scares or suspense. The tonal shifts between drama, allegory, musical, and horror can be jarring – it's like Coogler couldn't quite decide what kind of movie he was making.
But man, when this film works visually and musically, it's absolutely stunning. Shot on IMAX and Ultra Panavision 70mm, every frame looks like a painting. The way they use natural lighting and film stock creates this rich, textured world that pulls you right into 1930s Mississippi. And the music – it's not just a soundtrack, it's the soul of the film. These live-recorded blues performances feel so authentic and powerful, especially combined with Ludwig Göransson's resonator guitar-driven score. That musical sequence where Sammie's song literally tears open reality? That might be one of the most emotionally powerful scenes I've seen all year.
What makes Sinners so fascinating, is how everything in the story represents something deeper. The vampire doesn't just want to kill people - he offers them immortality, but only if they give up everything that makes them who they are. The attack on the juke joint isn't just about vampires either - it represents how Black communities and their gathering places have been destroyed over and over throughout history. The film also explores spiritual beliefs and old wounds passed down through families, especially through a character named Annie who practices Hoodoo (a type of folk magic), but even her own community and husband reject her for it. All of this makes the movie pretty complex - you need to understand some history about blues music, racism in the 1930s, and spiritual traditions to really get what Coogler is trying to say.
That cultural and historical density might be the film's biggest barrier. I watched it with friends who felt completely lost because they didn't have the background knowledge Coogler seems to assume viewers will have. It's not that these themes aren't worth exploring – they absolutely are, but the film doesn't always do the work to make them accessible to casual viewers. You either click with its wavelength or you don't, and there's not much middle ground.
Sinners is the kind of movie that's impossible to categorize neatly, and I suspect that's exactly what Coogler intended. Some people are going to walk out feeling like they watched an overlong, muddled mess with pretentious ambitions. Others will see it as a haunting, genre-defying work of art that trusts its audience with complex themes. The fact that it's sparked such passionate debates probably means it succeeded in ways that - safer, more conventional films never could.
Rather than spoon feeding you answers about its vampires or its mythology, Sinners invites you to sit with its moral ambiguity and interpret its symbols for yourself. That approach will alienate plenty of viewers who want clearer storytelling, but for a film about ghosts, music, memory, and the weight of history, maybe being divisive is exactly the point. It's messy and imperfect, but it's also genuinely trying to say something important about identity, survival, and what we're willing to sacrifice to belong somewhere.
Watch on Apple TV